Musmad Ahmad me Hulb Taai Rd. se Marvi rivayat ka haal..!!!

Musnad Ahmad wali rivayat ka haal:
iski sanad me ek raavi SIMAAK BIN HARB hai…jispar aimmae jarah wattaadeel ne sakht kalaam kiya hai…
1- Imam Sufiyan : ye zaeef hai.
2- Imam Shuabah : isko zaeef qarar dete hai.
3- Imam Ahmad : Ye Muztaribul hadis he.
4- Imam Salih : Yuz’af (ise zaeef qarar dete hai.)
5- Imam Nasai : Jab munfarid ho to bilkul qabile qubul nahi kyu ke ise talqeen ki jaati thi aur ye qabul kar leta tha.
6- Imam Ibne Ammar : muhaddiseen ka faisla he ke ye galtiyo ka shikar tha.
7- Imam Ibnul Mubarak : ZAEEF FIL HADIS hadis me zaeef hai.
8- Imam Ibne Kharaash : FEE HADEESUHU LEEN (iski hadis me gadbad he)
9- Imam Ibne Hibbaan : YUKHTI KASEERAA bohot khatakaar tha
10- Imam zahbi : ise zuafaa me shumar karte hai.
11: Imam ibne adi : ise zuafaa me shumar karte hai.
12- Imam ibne jauzi : ise zuafaa me shumar karte hai.
13- Imam aqeeli : ise zuafaa me shumar karte hai.
[ TEHZEEBUTTEHZEEB Jild:3 Pg:67, 68, MEEZAANUL AETEDAAL J:2 PG:216, AL MUGNI LIZZAHBI J:1 PG:448, AL KAAMIL LI IBNE ADI J:4 Pg:641, KITABUL ZUAFAA WAL MATRUKEEN LI IBNE JAUZI J:2 PG:26, KITABUL ZUAFAA ALKABEER LIL BAIHAQI J:2 Pg:178]
14- Imam Abul Qaasim Al Ka’bi r.a ne Simaak ko BAABU FEEHI ZIKRI MIN RUMUHU BI ANNAHU MIN AHLIL BID’I WA ASHAABIL AHWAA
(un logo ka bayan jinhe mujaddiseen ne Ahle Bidat aur Khwahish parast kaha he) ke tahat zikr kiya he.
[dekhiye QUBULUL AKHBAAR WA MA`RIFATURRIJAAL Jild;2 pg:381-390]

In Tasreehaat se sabit hua ke SIMAAK BIN HARB Jamhur Muhaddiseen ke nazdeek Zaeef hai.

Isme dusra raavi QABEESAH BIN HULB hai jo Indal Aimma Majhul hai.
-Imam Ibnul Madini aur Imam Nasai r.a farmate he: MAJHUL (ye majhul hai)
[TEHZEEBUT TEHZEEB Jild:5 Pg:325,326]

Pas ye rivayat SIMAAK BIN HARB K SHADEED ZOAF aur QABEESAH ki jahalat ki wajah se sakht zaeef aur naqabile hujjat hai. .

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s